saw this the other night after reading a lot about it. Sean Penn is a really good director, and i really enjoyed this film.
I can totally understand the motivations of alexander supertramp (as he called himself) but am not convinced id take it just as far as he did. Emile Hirschs performance is deservedly getting recognition but if hal holbrook is not up for best supporting actor then there is something severely wrong at the academy.
And the music by that nice mr vedder is superb too.